Opinion: Why Shakira’s record-breaking song is such a stigma hit

Editor’s be aware: Zimina N. Beltran Kwan Keo is a Chicago-based communications specialist and author. The opinions expressed listed below are her personal. Learn extra Opinion on CNN.


Final week, Shakira did with former soccer star Gerard Pique what each one that has been abused and underappreciated by their companion needs they might. She dismissed his ego and within the course of reminded herself – and the world – of what she may do.

Jimena N. Beltran Quan Keo

Inside 24 hours, “BZRP Music Session #53”, her newest single alongside Argentinian producer and DJ Bizarab, hit a file. 63 million views on YouTube and 14.4 million streams on Spotify. The catchy pop tune is a good addition to the separate songs canon, but it surely’s greater than only a competent observe about her ex and the daddy of her two kids. By airing her grievances in such a public discussion board, Shakira made an explosive and important cultural assertion by refusing to hold any disgrace related to the top of their relationship.

however in it The issue is. Not everybody agrees along with her method. The headlines round her single took on a sexual tone and described her conduct as “frivolous”, calling the tune a “retaliation hit”. Social media customers are questioning if Shakira broke an unwritten rule amongst ladies by pulling out the flame of her new ex. Others are completely happy to look at the drama unfold whereas judging her for posting her soiled garments.

Gerard Pique and Shakira on May 30, 2015 in Barcelona, ​​Spain.

We have heard the stigmatization of girls experiencing heartbreak earlier than. Most notably with Taylor Swift. in 2014 interviewSwift responded to criticism that she was drawing on her previous experiences.

“You are going to have people who find themselves going to say, ‘Oh, you understand, like she solely writes songs about her ex-boyfriends,'” the singer stated. “And I truthfully assume that is a really sexist angle. No one says that about Ed Sheeran. No one says that about Bruno Mars. They’re all writing songs about their exes, their present girlfriends, their love lives, and no one raises a crimson flag there.”

And she or he is correct. Simply take a look at Unhealthy Bunny. His Spanish-language album “Un Verano Sin Ti” He broke file after file And it gained first place for the Billboard album of the 12 months. The title translated means “Summer time With out You” — its unhappy theme is positioned instantly into the title and repeated all through nearly all of his 23 songs. Nevertheless, on-line searches for the Puerto Rican singer, alongside together with his album title, don’t instantly result in criticisms from these round him for monetizing it. His love life – it pays tribute to his genius and creativity.

In a viral tweet posted the identical day the tune was launched, person Melanie Mora Murillo broke down all of the delicate methods Shakira takes her intimate data of Pique and turns it right into a weapon, leaving little doubt (if there’s any) who she’s referring to. Highlights from the subject embody: declaring how Bizarrap samples eclipse “Me Enamoré” (“I Fell in Love”), a 2017 tune Shakira carried out about her relationship with Pique on the time, and highlighting how Shakira repeats her lyrics to insinuate to numerology. of their relationship. at 2:22 she sings “I am greater than twice as wealthy as a 22-year-old lady,” not only a reference to I discussed my youthful pal (Now 23; he shall be 36 subsequent month) However the ex-husband joint birthday February 2, 10 years aside. She additionally makes use of Pique’s signature gesture Two fingers up with each palms.

To really respect the warmth behind the tune, it’s important to watch it paired with the video, the place Shakira’s physique language provides one other layer of complexity. The digicam focuses on her when she assaults her former flame, she takes up house and throws her physique round her, exhibiting confidence and energy. It is a far cry fromMonotonia,” launched October 2022. Within the music video for Monotonia, she spends more often than not crying, trying raveled and singing “It wasn’t my fault, it wasn’t yours, the monotony was accountable.” ”

And that is the place we actually see Shakira elevating the jets, saying (with a fairly pointed play on the phrases on her ex-husband’s final title in addition) “I perceive it isn’t my fault if I get criticized, I simply play the music, sorry if I soiled you.” Her impact of claiming “she’s simply making music” is the one time she takes a modest method, appropriating stereotypes of girls as weak and comfortable to her benefit.

She places her troubles at his ft and affords an perception into what retains them up at evening – having his mom as a neighbor, the press hounding her not solely in regards to the breakup but additionally cost of tax evasion If convicted, she faces eight years in jail and a effective of as much as $25 million (she has repeatedly denied expenses her). Having navigated the obstacles she faces after his departure, issues that may be crushing underneath regular circumstances, she doubles down on her religion in herself and brings the traitorous different ladies into the fold by saying, “Girls not cry, ladies revenue from cash.”

This tune might have been made as a labor of survival — she calls it “therapeutic” and sings that she has to “resolve” herself from her ache — however there is not any denying that it is money-making and exhibits the world she’s nonetheless getting it. she Cashing Undoubtedly. However by being so open about what she’s going by, she’s stepped as much as her energy and gained. I rejected societal expectations and pressures to behave a sure approach as a long-term relationship ended. Within the course of, I made a The most important look of the Spanish language in Spotify historical past (a exceptional feat within the post-Unhealthy Bunny “Un Verano Sin Ti” period).

As a girl whose ex-partner is now her ex–a painful reminder of what occurs once you settle for lower than you deserve–Shakira works to remind others of a common reality. There is no such thing as a information to the worst moments in your life. There’s a excellent likelihood that somebody will criticize you for every little thing you do throughout remedy, so you might as properly do no matter feels best for you.

Leave a Comment